I’ve used a lot of browsers in my time, going back as far as Mosaic and Netscape Navigator. For a long time, I’ve been using Brave as my daily driver, but I’ve reached the point where it’s time to move on. I’m switching to a different open-source option instead.
What pushed me away from Brave
I don’t want to pay to remove features I didn’t ask for
I started using Brave several years ago. It worked with the Chrome extensions that I use, was blazing fast, and offered ad blocking by default, making watching YouTube a joy instead of a nightmare. While Brave used to be a good option to escape the feature bloat of Chrome, it’s sadly becoming bloated itself.
In 2023, some Brave users found that Brave VPN services and binaries were being installed without consent, even if people weren’t using the VPN service. Then Brave added its Leo AI assistant to the browser and search bar. Other issues include adding its own crypto wallet to the browser and cluttering the start page with sponsored cards and an ad-supported Brave News feed.
The straw that broke the camel’s back was the introduction of Brave Origin, a paid version of Brave on macOS and Windows that strips out the bloat, removing things such as Leo AI, Brave Rewards, Brave Wallet, Brave VPN, and Brave News. It is possible to disable some of these features without paying, but the underlying code is still hanging around in the background. Having to pay to remove bloat doesn’t sit well with me.
I considered several browser options
Many recommendations didn’t fit my needs
Credit: Jorge Aguilar / How To Geek | Mozilla
Go on any forum discussing browsers, and you’ll find die-hard fans of many different options. When people ask about browsers to use instead of Brave, there are several names that regularly crop up.
Firefox is one of the most common suggestions, and while I used Firefox for several years in the past, the issue is that I have some Chrome extensions that I use for work that don’t work in Firefox but do work in other Chromium-based browsers such as Brave. This is the biggest reason why I didn’t switch back to Firefox.
Another popular suggestion is LibreWolf, which has a big focus on privacy. This comes with some trade-offs that affect its usability. For example, cookies and website data are cleared when you close the browser, and the privacy features can be so strict that some websites may not work properly. While privacy is important, usability was more of a factor for me.
Vivaldi is also a common suggestion, but this isn’t completely open-source. While a lot of the code is published, some of the UI code is proprietary, so I ruled this one out, too.
Related
Sick of Being Tracked? These Browsers Put Your Privacy First
Which browsers actually shut out snoops, lock down your data, and let you choose your level of privacy?
I finally landed on Helium
Ad and tracker blocking out of the box
In the end, after considering the pros and cons of the various options, I ended up installing Helium. Helium is a free and fully open-source browser that has a focus on privacy and ad-blocking. It’s built on Chromium, just like Brave.
Also like Brave, Helium has ad and tracker blocking by default, through uBlock Origin and community filters. Watching YouTube is just as joyous as it is using Brave, because you don’t have to sit through endless annoying ads.
Helium also works with Chrome extensions, so I can use the extensions that I use on a daily basis for my work. It supports older MV2 extensions, and the website says that Helium will keep support for these older extensions for as long as possible. Requests to the Chrome Web Store are also anonymized, so Google can’t track which extensions you download.
A personal favorite feature for me is that Helium supports bangs, which allow you to search specific sites using text shortcuts such as !gi monkeys to search Google Images for monkeys. Brave has bang support too, but Helium has a dedicated bang for the Home Assistant community forums, which I use on a regular basis. While you can build custom search shortcuts in Brave, it’s nice to have a Home Assistant bang that’s ready-made.
Helium isn’t perfect
It’s still not the finished article
Credit: wutzkohphoto/Shutterstock.com
That’s not to say that Helium is perfect. It has several issues that aren’t major deal-breakers for me but may be for many other people.
A big omission is that there’s no sync; if you want to use Helium over multiple devices and have bookmarks and history carry over from device to device, you’re out of luck. There’s also no mobile version of Helium; it’s currently only available for macOS, Windows, and Linux.
Another major issue is that there’s no Widevine DRM support by default. This means that playing DRM-protected content from some streaming services such as Netflix or Spotify in Helium isn’t possible by default. If you use your browser for streaming, Helium is a bad fit.
The software is also still in beta, and while the website states that Helium installs updates automatically on macOS, it does not make the same claim for Windows and Linux. Since I’m using Helium on a Mac, this isn’t an issue for me.
Helium isn’t right for everyone
I’m not saying Helium is the best alternative to Brave for everybody. For many people, the lack of sync, lack of a mobile app, or inability to watch Netflix or use Spotify may make using Helium a non-starter. For my needs, however, it’s a great fit.
