Google’s AI Overviews feature is reportedly presenting entries from the SCP Foundation, a popular fan fiction universe built around fake horror “anomalies,” as though they describe real creatures and events. Futurism found at least 20 cases where the AI-generated summaries skipped any mention that the SCP entries are fiction.
Confusing made-up monsters as the real thing
A search for “SCP-565” reportedly returned an AI Overview describing an “anomalous, ambulatory human head” that moves like a crab and is tied to forensic records and a deceased man’s identity. The summary even pointed users toward an “official” SCP document for further reading.
Futurism
Futurism
According to Futurism, a search for “SCP-426,” a fictional toaster that supposedly makes anyone who mentions it talk about it in first person, generated a response written in first person, with the AI describing itself as the toaster and detailing fabricated injuries from people trying to imitate it. Other examples cited in the report included “SCP-922,” called “Another Version of the Truth,” and “SCP-779,” a parasite said to mimic a fairy.
In each case, the AI Overview reportedly treated the SCP Foundation’s invented documentation as legitimate research rather than flagging it as fiction. This isn’t the first time Google’s AI-powered search results have confidently presented false information as fact, with past slip-ups ranging from wrong dates to invented historical claims.
No acknowledgment, no disclaimer
The SCP Foundation’s own website states clearly that its entries are fictional. Google’s AI Overviews rarely repeated that context, Futurism notes, occasionally referencing “lore” without explaining what that meant. Futurism reached out to Google for comment but did not receive a response before publishing.`
I tried to replicate these findings, but a search for “SCP-565” did not return an AI Overview at all, and Google’s AI Mode labeled the entity a “fictional anomaly” rather than presenting it as real. Trying to reproduce this behavior with other fictional characters in the SCP universe also came up empty, suggesting Google may have already addressed the issue, at least for some of the queries Futurism flagged. Google has previously rolled out updates aimed at making AI Overviews and AI Mode more reliable, though accuracy issues have continued to surface from time to time.
Pranob Mehrotra / Digital Trends
Pranob Mehrotra / Digital Trends
Although I wasn’t able to replicate this behavior, the mistake still matters because AI Overviews sit at the top of many Google searches, and anyone unfamiliar with the SCP community, including children, could come away believing the stories are documented fact rather than horror fiction. It echoes other AI Overview missteps, including an instance where the feature recommended adding non-toxic glue to pizza sauce, a reminder that confidently wrong answers remain a persistent risk in AI-powered search.
